Fesmire was last seen at a friend's house in Lewiston, Maine on July 1, 2011. She has never been heard from again. She was reported missing after she didn't show up for a family gathering on July 4. Although she was depressed over the recent suicide of a friend, it's uncharacteristic of her to leave without telling anyone. She is a certified personal care assistant, but was unemployed at the time of her disappearance. She had advertised her services as a model on the internet, asking photographers to contact her if they were interested.

In October 2011, Buddy Robinson was charged with Fesmire's murder. He and his twin sister, Brandi, lived in the upstairs apartment in a two-unit building on Highland Avenue, and Fesmire lived downstairs. Brandi was running an escort business that advertised on the internet; Fesmire was one of the women who worked for her. Authorities believe Buddy drowned Fesmire in the bathtub and transported her body to another location in his sister's Lexus. Brandi eventually told the police that Buddy had confessed the murder to her. She has been granted immunity from prosecution for the prostitution-related offenses in exchange for her testimony against her brother. Buddy is awaiting trial.

Fesmire's remains have never been found.

Above: Buddy Robinson