Holland was last seen on June 10, 1983. He met a friend at her residence in the 3300 block of Hamburg Road in Eldorado, Ohio that day. He has never been heard from again. Holland's family found his vehicle in Lynn, Illinois days later. Foul play is suspected in Holland's case; authorities believe it may be connected to two drug-related murders in the local area. When the police searched the Hamburg Road farmhouse where Holland was supposed to meet his friend, they found no sign of him, but they did find a bullet they think may have been tied to his case.

Holland lived in Richmond, Indiana at the time of his disappearance, and that city's police are investigating. His parents are now deceased, but his brother and sister are still alive and his sister is actively looking for him.