Meyers was last seen in Clallam County, Washington on September 1, 2004. Authorities believe he went fishing that day in his 19-foot boat, which was moored at the LaPush Marina. The Coast Guard later found the boat, still running, eight miles south of LaPush at the mouth of Goodman Creek. There was no sign of Meyers.

Meyers lived in Sequim, Washington in 2004. He is a dentist who tended Quileute Indians in LaPush three times a week. He is presumed to be lost at sea.