Weisbecker was last seen at the home he shared with his mother and sister in the 200 block of Asbury Avenue in Ocean City, New Jersey on March 11, 2009. That morning, he sent his mother out to buy him some shirts. He was at home at 11:00 a.m., when the postal carrier delivered the mail. About an hour after that, his mother tried to call him but the call went straight to voice mail. When she arrived home at 8:30 that evening, Weisbecker was gone and his car, a Lincoln LS, was in the driveway. There was mail piled on the counter, including an unemployment benefit check for Weisbecker, and the kitchen stools were pushed out of place, but nothing else appeared to be out of the ordinary. His mother reported his disappearance to police at midnight.

Weisbecker was unemployed at the time of his disappearance, but he was about to start a new restaurant job and he planned to attend culinary school in the fall. His dream was to own his own restaurant. His vehicle has since been repossessed. His wallet and cellular phone disappeared with him, but he hasn't accessed his bank accounts or used his credit card or phone since he went missing. It's uncharacteristic of Weisbecker to leave without warning or to have his cellular phone turned off. He normally drove everywhere he went, even if his destination was only a few blocks away.

Weisbecker grew up in Ocean City and graduated from Ocean City High School in 2006. His case remains unsolved.